Category Archives: Sandwiches

Baked Bagel Sandwiches

Woah! Slow down! You in a hurry? Well you still have to eat, and if you’re like me, you have to feed your family too. Don’t panic, because I’ve got just the thing! It’s easy, quick, delicious, and best of all, they can be made to each individual’s tastes. I have picky eaters in this house, so finding something everyone  loves is a challenge. There’s always that one person, know what I mean? These also work well for lunches.

Let me introduce you to my version of Baked Bagel Sandwiches. Like I said, these would make an excellent lunch, but I served them for a quick dinner. All you’d need is a quick tossed salad, or maybe some french fries to serve along side it and wham bam! You’ve got yourself a dinner! And because it calls for meats and cheeses you like, everyone ends up happy!

Shh… you hear that? That’s the sound of no one fussing! Doesn’t get better than that! So lets build these right quick. Here we go!

Now, I know my family and I love bold flavors, so I chose the onion bagels. You can use whatever kind of bagel suits you. Although I wouldn’t use any of the sweet variety, that might be a little odd. 😂

So split your bagels and place the bottoms in a 13×9 baking dish. Then add 1 slice of cheese, pile on however much meat you want, then the 2nd slice of cheese, and your bagel tops.

Now take your small bowl an melt your butter in the microwave. Once it’s melted, stir in the horseradish mustard with a fork just to combine it. Now you’re gonna drizzle that over the tops of your bagel sandwiches, cover the dish with aluminum foil, and bake them for about 20-30 minutes. We just want to warm them through and melt that cheese.

That’s it! That’s all there is to it! Now you’re ready to enjoy!


Print Recipe
Baked Bagel Sandwiches Yum
Recipe by Christine Titus
Course Sandwiches
Cuisine American
Course Sandwiches
Cuisine American
  1. Preheat oven to 350°.
  2. Split the bagels and place bottom halves in a 13x9 baking dish.
  3. Layer a slice of cheese on each bottom half, then pile on your meat or combination of meats, then second slice of cheese and finally the bagel tops.
  4. In a small bowl, whisk together melted butter and horseradish mustard. Drizzle over bagel tops.
  5. Cover with aluminum foil and bake for 20-30 minutes until warm throughout and the cheese is melted.
Recipe Notes

Adapted from Thomas Bagels

Share this Recipe

Slow Cooker Hawaiian Chicken

As soon as the weather just hints at warmer days to come, I start craving that warm weather food! You know, like grilled burgers, cold salads, corn on the cob!!! OMG Corn on the cob! One of my favorite things to eat during the warmer seasons. I saw a pile of it at the grocery store on my last trip, and took a peek at them, and they were beautiful! Can’t believe I only bought 3! I knew I was only really feeding it to myself and kids, but it was perfect corn! I’m hoping they have some more when I go back this week. Oh, and yea, just myself and my kids on the corn. If I haven’t mentioned this before, my husband is to corn like a vampire is to garlic. Not kidding. He hates the stuff. Not even corn bread! He won’t touch it. I could complain, but honestly, more for me!! HA!

Another one of my favorite foods during the warmer months are shredded (or pulled) meat sandwiches, put on a hamburger bun or Kaiser roll, dripping with delicious sauce, and topped with yummy coleslaw (or like my kids, put the coleslaw on the side). I normally decide on the main dish and THEN figure out the side dish, but since I saw this corn, it came first and I needed a main dish. I wanted something that was really going to wow my taste buds, and make my kids cheer my name. I have thousands of recipes in my files, but seriously, nothing jumped out at me 😂 so I hopped on over to Lemon Tree Dwelling, one of my favorite food blogs. If you haven’t checked it out, you should! Cathy over there, really knows how to wow your taste buds! I took one look at her Slow Cooker Hawaiian Chicken and already knew it was perfect! So that’s what I’m sharing with you today, is her perfect, delicious, out of this world, Slow Cooker Hawaiian Chicken. You can’t go wrong with this one folks. It’s so easy, and one bite, you’ll think you’re in heaven! Here’s my insanely bad picture, (😂 I’m trying to get better! I swear!) and her wonderful recipe. Make this!! Take it to a potluck, or just serve it to your family because it’s pure love! You won’t regret it!